Last Stand of the FL Keys-letter. Supported by Florida Bay Forever

SSPOA

Sugarloaf Shores Property Owners Association

Dear Sugarloafers:

At the next meeting of the Monroe County Board of County Commissioners (BOCC) on Wednesday, October 21, at the Marathon Government Center at approximately 11 am, the BOCC will be considering the 2026 US 1 Level of Service (LOS) study, which reaches a passing grade for traffic on the Overseas Highway. This means that developers will not be required to mitigate for the traffic impacts of new projects in the unincorporated County.

Average computed speeds on the highway per the LOS studies keep increasing. But our eyes tell us that traffic on the highway has been getting worse, not better. For this reason, a Citizens Committee was recently formed to analyze the 2026 LOS study and the LOS methodology on which the study is based.

The Committee has found a number of flaws in the LOS methodology, particularly regarding the treatment of certain types of traffic delays. Four types of delay events (construction, school buses, school zones, and openings of the Snake Creek drawbridge) are being excluded form travel times, meaning the slowdown is ignored. The Committee believes this is wrong because, unlike on the mainland, there is no way to detour around delays on the Overseas Highway, our one road into and out of the Keys. Under the LOS methodology, there is also an artificial reduction in travel times related to traffic signals that is inappropriately applied uniformly to all signals on the highway.

The Committee believes that these flaws result in inflated computed speeds on the highway and inflated excess capacity of the highway per the LOS studies. As a result, the LOS studies are virtually guaranteed to reach a passing grade.

SSPOA is one of 24 organizations throughout the Keys and the state that have signed a letter to the BOCC requesting that the BOCC reconvene a special task force to review the LOS methodology. That letter is reprinted below. We are asking that the task force analyze the flaws in the methodology and instances where the requirements of the methodology are not being followed in the LOS studies. We also want the task force to make recommendations regarding supplemental runs which the BOCC ordered in 2021 to address the fact that none of the regular LOS runs are made during the Key West morning rush hour period. Finally, the task force should consider updating the LOS methodology to reflect modern approaches to average speed measurement.

Please consider attending Wednesday’s BOCC meeting, making comments at that meeting in person or via Zoom, or writing the BOCC to show your support for our request.

The SSPOA Board

Click to read the letter sent to the BOCC